Why Black Holes Could Delete The Universe - The Information Paradox

Share
Embed
  • Published on Aug 24, 2017
  • Black holes are scary things. But they also might reveal the true nature of the universe to us.
    This video was realised with the help of Dr. Alessandro Sfondrini and it was funded by SNSF under Agora Grant n. 171622 and through the NCCR SwissMAP: The Mathematics of Physics.
    See also our video on String theory: bit.ly/2HXClLH
    Kurzgesagt Newsletter: eepurl.com/cRUQxz
    Support us on Patreon so we can make more videos (and get cool stuff in return): www.patreon.com/Kurzgesagt?ty=h
    Kurzgesagt merch: bit.ly/1P1hQIH
    The music of the video here:
    Soundcloud: bit.ly/2vqZNtB
    Bandcamp: bit.ly/2v8zn4q
    Facebook: bit.ly/2qW6bY4
    THANKS A LOT TO OUR LOVELY PATRONS FOR SUPPORTING US:
    Tommy Palm, Rob Kay, Krystian Jagoda, Nathaniel Caza, Ing Apilitkitsmai, Felix Nilsson, Andrew Czarnietzki, Curtis Light, Shalay Hudson, Devin Harris, Sascha Holste, Garret Robinson, Eric Korhonen, Ivy McLeod, Jonathan Smithson, Kristin Wolff, Bram Vandenbogae, Dane Shea, Jean Rossi, Tom Hoy, Nick, Luke Chromy, Benjamin Rich, Florian Wilke, Nomubiku, Brad Gordon, Alec Wassill, Andrew Ferrell, André Campos, Andrea Stiffelman, Annette Allen, Luke England, Quique Bengochea, Mikael Linderholm, Robin Fernandes, Gabriel Marante, Jonathan Kelly, Christian Frinken, JD Manuel, Simon Naus, Matthew Remillard, James Camidge, Joao Neves, Brenton Doherty, Janet Low, Lucy Zhang, Harry Kingsley, Allan Lazo, Aleksandar Milanov, Lennart Hensler, John P., zjweele13, Simon Strandgaard, Owen, Drake Hardy, Harry Dong, Lci larocci, Graham Shumway, Jona Derks, David Matlock, Hans Wurst, Steven Boliek, Paul Chensy, Philip Preston, Daniel Du, Oskuro, Mark Simonson, Mārtiņš Zinbergs. Dylan Mason, Cameron Stewart, Joanne Chou, Andrew O’Neill, Ramsay Kamal, Dani Rabinowitz, Vlad Zinchenko, Dennis Kaur, Benjamin Davis, Waltimus Prime, Daniele A. muchtas, Matt Randall, Ani, Quintc, Eugene Zingerman, Stephen Collis, Kevin Keogh, Scott Stevens, John Cantwell, Marcin Lepczyk, Jannik Wagner, John Tschampel, David, Augusto, Mike Rotondo, Matthew Leibowitz, Martin Gauer, ShiroKuma, William Closson, Jeff Cerminar, Marc Kuiper, Samuel Choy, Per Opedal, Oddysen, TJ, Váradi Bence, Marcie Shepherd, Ken Rutabana, Roman Rys, Chase Reynolds, Nathan Skirrow, Charles Mowers, Brandon Lane, Mitch Haggman, Patrick Nobl, vladimir šebez, Nicholas Evers, David Hirsch, Misko Giboreau, Friedrich Reider, Christian Massold, Björn Keßel, Ron Leonard, Johann Goergen, Tonina Zhelyazkova, Tony Nitowski, Geoffrey Major, William Bonwitt, Arslan Ablikim, James Tran, JP Hastings-Spital, Michael Shi, Anni Gill, Cymon Carlisle, bob smith, Jonathan Brunette, George Murray, John, Bryan Lawlor, Bjarne Kohnke, Christopher Isar, Renee Undrits, Joshua Hardin, Diego, Maggs, Akram Jamal-Allail, shoftee, Dattu Patel, Josh Heri, Christopher Dein DeltaNutmeg, Julian Hartline, Jesper Sølvsten, Adam Thompson, Amadon Faul, Ben Spicer, Dan-Dumitru Donici, Kaushik Narasimhan, Dennis Kok, Carlo Fajardo, Zaneksy, Rami Najjar, Rik Muschamp, César Rdez, David Marsden, Klasoweit, Gabrielle Gendron-Lepage, Nicholas, Nathan Dietrich, Manolo Calderon, Gil Nemesh, Caleb, Karthik Sekar, Jean-Francois Blain, Travis Harger, Jose Zamora, Danilo Metzger, Olle Karlberg, TJ, Patrick Hart, SCPNostalgia, Devin, David Oxley, Andy Hill, Maxime Cony, Vjenceslav, Neil Mukhopadhyay, Cory Bosse, Kara M., Dogydogsun, Andy Zeng, Angela Flierman, Tyler Alden, Klaus Prünster, Alex Boyd, Diana Martínez, Danny Fast, Bryce Watson, Chan Maneesilasan, Johanna Lind, Orphansmith, 彥霖 陳, Emanuel Hafner, James Dominguez, Kevin Hackbarth, Pablo Pagano, Liam Quin, Dan Rossiter, James Phan, Leon Klang, Romain Isnel, Anthony Eales, Freebite, Logan Rankin, Udi Eylat

    Help us caption & translate this video!
    usclip.net/user/timedtext_cs_panel?c=UCsXVk37bltHxD1rDPwtNM8Q&tab=2
    How Black Holes Could Delete The Universe - The Information Paradox

Comments • 26 125

  • Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell

    There's brand new stuff in the Kurzgesagt Merch Shop. Check it out here: shop.kurzgesagt.org

    • Prashanth Gandra
      Prashanth Gandra 9 days ago

      Kurzgesagt - In a Nutshell 🇺🇦🇹🇱🇸🇾🇰🇳🇹🇱🇹🇨🇸🇪🇹🇼🇹🇰🇰🇷🇱🇰🇻🇦🇸🇿🇹🇬🇹🇲🇹🇳🇹🇰🇹🇨🇺🇾🇦🇪🇸🇿🇺🇦🇹🇰🇱🇰🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇸🇸🇷🇱🇨🇸🇪🇸🇿

    • Skelly
      Skelly 14 days ago

      U say that every vid lol

    • Kenneth Dang
      Kenneth Dang 18 days ago

      Hey, Kurzgesagt, can you do a video on P vs NP, or any other of the 7 millennial problems on the clay mathematics institute?

  • Aki Greus
    Aki Greus 5 hours ago

    Does the flat earth group mean flat universe? :D

  • first name last name
    first name last name 7 hours ago +1

    9:28 congratulations 👏👏
    You just played yourself!!
    You just proved that the earth is flat!!(i am not a flat earther)

  • koodude2313
    koodude2313 8 hours ago

    "Black holes are the ultimate hard drive"

    LMFAO gtfo of here.

  • jose g.
    jose g. 11 hours ago

    What if when the black hole dies and that's the big bang

  • A Good Show
    A Good Show 12 hours ago

    Yeetus feetus the universe has been deletus

  • Spot Catmaster
    Spot Catmaster 18 hours ago

    who hates when their bannana becomes a squirrel

  • CH N
    CH N 19 hours ago

    did CERN deleted our universe?

  • Grim rblx
    Grim rblx 21 hour ago +1

    What if ounce the last black hole dies off it makes a big bang recreating the universe?

  • SrgSlaughter
    SrgSlaughter 21 hour ago

    Earth: a black holes not gonna eat us
    Black hole:dinner time nom
    Earth: aughhhhh help :(

  • Manoj Kumar
    Manoj Kumar Day ago

    If blackhoole can store information, is there any way where we can use blackhole as a supercomputer??

  • Vance Gilbert
    Vance Gilbert Day ago

    The problem with imagining yourself falling in a black hole is that you can not experience time "while" in a black hole that is in the same universe as when you left: Metabolic rates involve electrons, and the nature of the black hole itself is that it naturally strips the electrons off of the nucleus of atoms by pushing the atomic centers closer together, the clouds of electrons being forced away from their nucleus by the crowding of other atom nuclei is the same problem with everything entering the influence of the event horizon; there is a very real shedding of electrons that many physicists say must "spaghettify" the matter crossing such a horizon because some scientist got the idea that every atom must go through some incredibly small hole it can't fit through.
    This is completely false.
    It supposes that space gets too tight for a single atomic nuclei to go through the center of the black hole. This is a misinterpretation of the local environment of the black hole: everyone assumes that the cloud of electrons around a black hole, in the accretion disk means that the metabolism of the item (it's literal clock of an electron circling around the nuclei acts as a perpetual oscillation machine that links us to our atomic nuclei into a "time" in space.) going into the black hole must be the same as the "metabolic clock" of the atoms you use to see with your eyes.
    This is where your perspective is patently false when compared to the rate of time perceived by the "victim" of the black hole that is falling inside.
    To them the horizon would slip above their view and stop with nothing in view, and time would return with the view of the universe coming back into place around you as space started to fall inside as well, allowing you to perceive time only after the electrons have started to permeate into a black hole's environment, and that is only after the black hole has evaporated; literally keeping the atoms from experience space or time for the entire existence of the back hole itself.
    This removed the atoms from the time of the old universe because the energy that made up the electrons of the atoms in the heart of the black hole had to wait for the black hole to evaporate again due to Hawking radiation, for them to start having a regular existence compared to the previous space time on the other side of the black hole's event horizon.
    We get separated by time, and we unfold back into regular space in an almost inconceivably long period of duration expected of the eventual vacuum death of the universe, which is the half life of every stable molecule in the black hole. That is the time passed when the nuclei escapes in a white hole to return to the fabric of space once again released to meet up with their counterpart electrons. According to the second law of thermodynamics, energy can not be created or destroyed, merely transmuted into the other and back again.
    Essentially time is turned into a solid when you are in a black hole, and then it is returned back into a fluid when you return to "regular" space. That solid chunk of time that is an eternity until the black hole turns into a white hole is NOT experienced by any atom separated from it's electron.
    That nuclei was transformed into a non-time experiencing oscillation that forced the molecules to start vibrating to when it crossed the event horizon: that is the event, matter synchronizing in oscillation between the universe, and the compacted nuclei of all the matter that fell into it before then.
    This suggests that time will not be experienced UNTIL that black hole evaporates because the nuclei is synchronized to a different frequency, that of the black hole that absorbed the matter in the first place.

  • epiclemongamingbros

    If we r in a black hole, then how r there black holes is the universe checkmate!

  • Melchior Hof
    Melchior Hof Day ago +1

    I am a bachelor of science and would like to fight this thesis: If you burn a piece of paper, the information is lost! You may store the atom soup in a bag. But unless you prior to this have stored all atom positions (on a hard drive?). You will never be able to arrange the paper back again.
    Why would a VERY destructive black hole store this delicate information?

  • Callum Ross24
    Callum Ross24 Day ago

    Spectacular

  • Chuck Bird 36
    Chuck Bird 36 Day ago

    BLACK HOLE IS 100,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 YEARS!!!

  • Emily Schad
    Emily Schad 2 days ago

    1:24 interstellar!

  • Argon
    Argon 2 days ago

    1:05 yes Patrick

  • Roelant G
    Roelant G 2 days ago

    4:24 MY LIFE IS A LIE

  • Himanshu Sai
    Himanshu Sai 2 days ago

    2:49 Minecraft Crafting Recipies

  • Prateek Pandey
    Prateek Pandey 2 days ago

    So you mean to say that it's possible that our whole universe could be inside a black hole and someone out there could be watching us on their 2-D screen. Wicked 😵😅😂

  • Shutdown Charter 100

    Hurts my brain! Hey wait a second, the end of the url is "GETiQ"




    Fact: 98% of the people reading this will check.

  • Faris Durrani
    Faris Durrani 2 days ago

    The thought of us being in a virtual reality inside a black hole is itself unsettling. But that just means we have a lot more to learn. Thanks Kurzgesagt for making this amazing video!

  • Sebastian Camacho
    Sebastian Camacho 2 days ago +1

    “My life is a lie.”
    -Duck

  • QUESTIONMARK
    QUESTIONMARK 2 days ago +3

    *404: Gravity not found*

  • boaz
    boaz 3 days ago

    3:30 dat ash

  • No Name
    No Name 3 days ago

    Kurzgesagt is a german word but its an english chanel?

    • No Name
      No Name 2 days ago

      +Benstar985 i know i come from germany

    • Benstar985
      Benstar985 2 days ago

      No Name they have a german channel as well

  • FE2 and More -Roblox

    If black holes can delete the universe, can black holes rebuild the universe? :p

  • julius nadarang
    julius nadarang 3 days ago +5

    Give me a dollar for every "information" said

  • Devon Ferrier
    Devon Ferrier 3 days ago +6

    I consider a black hole to be the creation of a new universe, Multiverse theory? See me to be right or wrong, but proving either most likely impossible right now.

  • PlumpRook 62
    PlumpRook 62 3 days ago

    Bet

  • Andrew Aydie
    Andrew Aydie 3 days ago +3

    Reminder that none black have ever been direclty observed but just deduced so maybe even what science thinks of them now is wrong on a fundamental level, by that I mean we can never have a definitive definition about reality just a humanly digestible rationalization of it.

  • jayden geogreson
    jayden geogreson 3 days ago

    Guys comment me If u saw bendy’s head here check it just upside down 9:49

  • Pole Dev
    Pole Dev 3 days ago

    i want my computer hard disk Like Black Hole

  • scimatar5
    scimatar5 4 days ago

    Why do we have to be a 3D image stored on a 2D surface? Why can't we be a 4D image stored on a 3D surface? Wouldn't that make more sense? And couldn't that mean that the 4D form of the surface of our universe exists in a 5D universe, moving up as far as possible until any higher dimensions collapse in on themselves because they are too complex to exist?

  • Risyad Haris
    Risyad Haris 4 days ago

    can we actually rearrange atoms?

  • Abhijeet Dash
    Abhijeet Dash 4 days ago +1

    Got a new definition of *INFORMATION*

  • Patryk Obiedzinski
    Patryk Obiedzinski 4 days ago

    Basically matrix

  • Time To Share
    Time To Share 4 days ago +3

    0:04-0:07 That black hole WAS THANOS!

  • Ayelo
    Ayelo 4 days ago

    If you arrange certain atoms in a certain way, you get a banana.
    If you arrange those atoms in a different way, you get a squirrel.
    Suck on that one, vegans!

  • ShiiDox
    ShiiDox 4 days ago

    But what if we were in a black hole but never knew..

  • Köri Ball [AMB] [TMCAF] [İKM] [S&K]

    Black Hole:YEET

  • Elvin Chu
    Elvin Chu 4 days ago +1

    Would black hole be 6 or 7 dimensions that can store stuff in a variety area

  • sophie m
    sophie m 4 days ago

    Wtf I understand none of this

  • Mat Broadcast
    Mat Broadcast 4 days ago

    If the universe was a black hole then the Big Crunch theory would be the primary theory due to Hawking radiation and dark energy/the expansion of the universe is just the black hole gaining mass this also explains what truly happens with the mass black holes swallow and makes the fact that the universe just appeared out of nowhere much more believable

  • Jimmy Jim
    Jimmy Jim 4 days ago

    What would happen if a gamma ray hit a black hole?

  • Ryas Z
    Ryas Z 5 days ago +1

    I don't get it, if BH made every information the same, then why even bother the event horizon for data, it all became the same mush.

  • Mike The Mimikyu
    Mike The Mimikyu 5 days ago +1

    Well anything that goes in a black hole won't disappear forever, when a blackhole dies it becomes a whitehole ad will spew out all of the things it sucked up

  • *NPC* no.1515
    *NPC* no.1515 5 days ago +1

    Anime waifus exist in our world. They are just encoded at the event horizon of the black hole.

  • The CheesyBagel
    The CheesyBagel 5 days ago

    I want my 800 petabyte hard drive for my computer

  • Sabrina Hejjaj
    Sabrina Hejjaj 5 days ago

    I know this has nothing to do with the video but can anyone explain how they make such an animated videos because I need it for a schoolproject, thanks!

  • aitana romero
    aitana romero 5 days ago +1

    well we could send suicide bombers in there and see what happens

  • ZomBie guy MansTer
    ZomBie guy MansTer 6 days ago

    When humans make use of black holes aka infinite energy (shiva) thts when we are just making use of the energy made by god (kalyug ends and the lord makes more creation 🙏🏻⚡⚡⚡⚡❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ U science geeks say energy cant be created nor be destroyed the how the fuk did the big bang have infinite amount of energy to make so big of a universe

  • ZomBie guy MansTer
    ZomBie guy MansTer 6 days ago

    U knw y people don't believe god cu, it's infinite shiv ling looks like a black hole and in the shiv puran its written that shiva is the answer to all energy source⚡

  • Amna Kashif
    Amna Kashif 6 days ago

    8:05 Omg I always used to think there was a small chance it could be a hologram

  • DomiTastyVideos
    DomiTastyVideos 6 days ago

    Its like recover lost data from a harddrive even if you formated the harddrive you still can recover deleted data

  • SinsCritShot
    SinsCritShot 6 days ago +3

    black holes : Ha! Those tiny humans know nothing about me !
    kurzgesagt : What

  • Manny Blackstar
    Manny Blackstar 6 days ago

    This all information is a hoax. The black holes are the Satan and the Universe is the God.

  • Knights of Camelot
    Knights of Camelot 6 days ago

    Throw a space camera into it📷

  • Larson Holleman
    Larson Holleman 6 days ago

    Black hole has a friend a mean one it is exotic matter

  • M.L. W.L.
    M.L. W.L. 6 days ago

    Dont know the math but if the black hole take 3D arranged matter and increases in volum by acquiring it its not an 3D -> 2D conversion right? It's just 3D -> 3D. Sorry for the bad english, not my native language.

  • António Paixão
    António Paixão 6 days ago

    Well ironically enough...
    The Blackholes are the solution to space expansion

  • FuzedPlayz
    FuzedPlayz 6 days ago

    Wow the universe is crazy just think we live here and while all this crazy stuff is going on your reading this comment

  • A Hand
    A Hand 6 days ago

    It's not deleted but compressed.

  • No Name
    No Name 6 days ago

    If a black hole swallow another black hole? : /

  • Xx T0M47O xX
    Xx T0M47O xX 6 days ago +2

    1:04 I saw the Patrick

  • 時氏
    時氏 7 days ago

    要するにアカシックレコードやらなんやら言われてたアレはブラックホールだった…?

  • Dzrian
    Dzrian 7 days ago +14

    "i would like a squirrel split"
    "You mean banana split"
    "What's the difference?"

    • Death Bone
      Death Bone 3 days ago +1

      The entire concept of the video

    • Michael C
      Michael C 3 days ago

      Dzrian 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • Dzrian
    Dzrian 7 days ago +1

    How life first came to be, was when rocks turned into animals.
    Stone: transforms*... becomes a fish

  • Dzrian
    Dzrian 7 days ago +2

    Anyone had that problem when they try to eat a banana, it becomes a squirrel?

  • GRACE Mata
    GRACE Mata 7 days ago

    Oopsss sorry mr.blackhole But Thanos already took out half of the universe. Maybe you can take the other half

  • Aidan Rader
    Aidan Rader 7 days ago

    I love your vids they super helpful

  • Jireh Choo
    Jireh Choo 7 days ago

    Thanos has left the chat

  • NuclearWolf LEGO Technic Design

    I got an add for laundry detergent after the video...

  • Jack devil Wolf
    Jack devil Wolf 7 days ago

    This hurt my brean

  • Coven
    Coven 7 days ago

    nice

  • donnell outlaw
    donnell outlaw 7 days ago +3

    Anyone sees Crank Lucas's song regarding Black Holes?
    Very good.

  • Roasted Wakidawg
    Roasted Wakidawg 7 days ago +2

    banana to squirrel - Kurgesagt
    hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm........

  • Crossbow123
    Crossbow123 8 days ago +2

    Would this idea of information also allow us to theoretically foresee the future as opposed to see the past? My idea here is that the whole universe is basically just a huge chain reaction. And usually one can determine the outcome of a reaction if one has every parameter (except in quantum physics of course). If I release a glass thats in my hand for example I can already tell the future by knowing that the reaction that follows will shatter the glass.

  • BlueStoneTimes
    BlueStoneTimes 8 days ago

    Wait, but how do we know what's on the other side of the black hole?? Everything just disappears.??

  • Tacianna Cristina
    Tacianna Cristina 8 days ago

    Oh the existential crisis...

  • Arthur Hartel
    Arthur Hartel 8 days ago +1

    Who else hates it when ur sun falls in on it self🤦‍♂️

  • EVERYONE MyUserNameIsNotThis

    Black Holes Die Soon.

  • Carla Saldarriaga
    Carla Saldarriaga 8 days ago

    My 5 year old son loves your videos

  • FireCarf
    FireCarf 9 days ago +11

    Black hole: *snaps*
    Universe: i don’t feel so good

  • lucky panda
    lucky panda 9 days ago +1

    hi

  • Teazal Angelous
    Teazal Angelous 9 days ago +1

    Love your videos so much honestly. I wish we could have a more in depth version, but I guess then it just wouldn't be Kurzgsagt!

  • Nicole Wai
    Nicole Wai 9 days ago

    I love this video and I would like to do more reading. May I get the reference websites? Or maybe book titles and articles?

  • The Helghan Empire
    The Helghan Empire 9 days ago +1

    New!
    Black hole Hard drives stores 100,000 Petabytes of Information!

  • massi amir
    massi amir 9 days ago

    Almost infinitely strong

  • FireFistPokemon
    FireFistPokemon 9 days ago

    You have solved the universe

  • Mathias Eriksson
    Mathias Eriksson 9 days ago

    String thermory solved: If everything that gets sucked in to a black hole does that in a tiny piece at the time, so it becomes a long string of the absolute tinyest buildingblocks of our universe. We would kind of have a 1D string of information stored in layers upon layers... and in this case, black holes just as they say in the video is a huge storage device. And we consist of long strings more or less. The known universe is the program running. Black holes are the backup disk. just an idéa :P /someone who knows nothing about this stuff.

  • Trolltabornok GT
    Trolltabornok GT 9 days ago

    But in part 1 you sad blackholes want to lose energy but if blackholes use information as energy to get bigger it never gonna end each star blackhole "eat" itget bigger blackholes are unkillebble

  • NotFlatEarthing
    NotFlatEarthing 10 days ago

    Me: *Can create/use/destroy black holes*
    Also me: reality can be whatever i want...

  • Richard Toralba
    Richard Toralba 10 days ago

    To be sure

  • Dallas King
    Dallas King 10 days ago

    This channel LOVES zeros, don't they?

  • Ali
    Ali 10 days ago

    that blackhole lady at the beginning of the video can git it. you go girl

  • Justin Valdez
    Justin Valdez 10 days ago

    i have had 20 nightmares thank you my good man

  • maybe a normalhuman
    maybe a normalhuman 10 days ago +12

    Me: *violently shoves sock into room*
    My mom: *WTF* WHY IS THERE A BLACK HOLE IN MY HOUSE

  • TB77
    TB77 10 days ago +2

    Sounds like the interstellar soundtrack