Challenge 74: Summing from the Year 2014 to N

  • Published on Jan 3, 2019
  • Congratulations to reynolds45, Zain Majumder, Vampianist3, Nicola C, Rishav Gupta, Kwekinator117, and adandap for successfully solving the last week's math challenge question! reynolds45 was the first person to solve the question.
    Your support is truly a huge encouragement.
    Please take a second to subscribe in order to send us your valuable support and receive notifications for new videos!
    Every subscriber and every like are wholeheartedly appreciated.
    Welcome, everyone! My channel hosts one weekly math challenge question per week (made by either myself, my family, or my friends), which will be posted every Wednesday. Please comment your proposed answer and explanation below! If you are among the first ten people with the correct answer, you will be recognized in the next math challenge video. The solution to this question and new question will be posted next Wednesday.
    For more Weekly Math Challenges:

Comments • 24

  • LetsSolveMathProblems
    LetsSolveMathProblems  5 months ago +10

    A few announcements:
    * Please watch the first 40 seconds. Thank you so much for all of your encouragement throughout 2018! As stated in the video, I'm truly blessed to have such a supportive and amiable audience.
    ** Due to a busy personal schedule, the solution to the last week's challenge will be posted on Friday or Saturday. You have my sincere apologies.
    *** The second semester (once I survive the chaos of the first few weeks) looks to be a much less stressful one for me, and I will endeavor to post as many non-Weekly-Math-Challenge videos as time permits. (A plethora of integration problems, Putnam, and AMC/AIME is on my bucket list.) =)

    • magnifecent
      magnifecent 5 months ago

      Are you in university?

    • QUANTUM city
      QUANTUM city 5 months ago +1

      Thank you to explain us awesome and interesting questions of mathamatics 😘

  • Miyuki Umeki
    Miyuki Umeki 5 months ago

  • Kyu Ho Lee
    Kyu Ho Lee 5 months ago +1

    How about actually substituting pi/4 on x? because the functions are periodic, might easily cancel out each other...
    + why did he say finding answers, when the only answer is 2019???

  • Ethereal Huldra
    Ethereal Huldra 5 months ago

    I think you should let us viewers have access to the work you put up on your videos. You can probably put a link in the description. That way viewers don't need to go to specific parts of the video to find how you solved certain parts of a problem.

  • mika2b
    mika2b 5 months ago

    Thank you for this challenge !

  • UbuntuLinux
    UbuntuLinux 5 months ago

    This is my solution:

  • adandap
    adandap 5 months ago +1

    Another week of summer holidays and another "oops, it was math challenge day". :)
    First, thank you so much for this channel. I've really enjoyed getting my eye back in for maths.
    Second, happy 2019 - which is also the answer to this (not very hard) problem. First write the LHS as Sum [sec(3x) * (sin(ix) cos(3x) - cos(ix) sin(3x) )] = sec(3x) Sum[sin(i-3)x]. Then multiply both sides by cos(3x). Then on the RHS you can use sin(3x)cos(ix) = 1/2 * [sin(3+i)x + sin(3-i)x] and the sum telescopes to give just six terms: sin(2011x)+sin(2012x)+ ... + sin(2016x). The LHS will have the same six terms iff N=2019.

  • Rishav Gupta
    Rishav Gupta 5 months ago

    The answer is 2019 by multiplying cos3x both sides we get on lhs
    Whre i is from 2014 to N
    Which implies sereis is
    On rhs we get
    Sin3x+sigma i from 1 to 2013(2sin(3x)cos(ix))
    =sin a-sin b
    On cancelling terms we get on right side
    Which implies

  • Daulian Doge
    Daulian Doge 5 months ago +1

    First I multiply cos3x to both sides which convert all tan3x into sin3x. Then at the LHS we see “sum(i=2014 -> N) of (cos3xsin(ix)-sin3xcos(ix))” which equal to “sum(i=2014->N) of (sin(ix-3x))” and in the RHS we see “sum(i=1->2013) of (2sin3xcos(ix))” equal to “sum(i=1->2013) of (sin(ix-3x)-sin(ix+3x))”. In RHS I separate “sum(i=1->2013) of (sin(ix+3x)-sin(ix-3x))” into “sum(i=1->2013) of (sin(ix+3x)) negative sum(i=1->2013) of (sin(ix-3x))” and add both sides with “sum(i=1->2013) of (sin(ix-3x))” which neutralize itself at RHS, I combine “sum(i=1->2013) of (sin(ix-3x))” with “sum(i=2014->N) of (sin(ix-3x))” and turn it into “sum(i=1->N) of (sin(ix-3x))”. Now I expand the RHS:

    RHS = sin3x + sum(i=1->2013) of (sin(ix+3x))
    = sin3x+sin4x+sin5x+...sin2016x

    -> sum(i=1->N) of (sin(ix-3x)) = sin3x+sin4x+sin5x+...sin2016x
    -> N=2019

    *Sorry for bad english btw :)) *

  • Shubham Kumar Yadav
    Shubham Kumar Yadav 5 months ago +1

    Answer is 2019.
    Shift all the terms containing tan 3x to one side, rearrange the terms a bit so that the formulae for summation from sin(x) to sin(nx) and similarly for cos x to cos nx can be used, simplify a bit to convert LHS and RHS in terms of tan, and then as the result is true for all x, thus, by direct comparison, the answer is N=2019.

  • Aswini Banerjee
    Aswini Banerjee 5 months ago

    The answer is as I guessed 2019.
    At first multiply both side by cos(3x) the equation becomes [∑cos(3x)sin(ix)-sin(3x)cos(ix) from 2014 to N] = sin(3x)+∑2sin(3x)cos(ix) from 1 to 2013
    Now cos(3x)sin(ix)-sin(3x)cos(ix)=sin{x(i-3)} and 2sin(3x)cos(ix)=sin(3x+ix)-sin(ix-3x)
    So [∑sin{x(i-3) from 2014 to N]=sin(3x)+∑sin(3x+ix)-sin(ix-3x) from 1 to 2013
    Now ∑sin{x(i-3)} from 2014 to N+∑sin(ix-3x) from 1 to 2013=sin(3x)+∑sin(3x+ix) from 1 to 2013
    Or ∑sin(ix-3x) from 1 to N=sin(3x)+∑sin(3x+ix) 1 to 2013
    Now substituting (i-3) and (i+3) by k (2 ks are different) we get
    [∑sin(kx) from 1 to N-3]-sin(x)-sin(2x)=sin(3x)+ ∑sin(kx) from 4 to 2016
    Or [∑sin(kx) from 1 to N-3]=sin(3x)+sin(2x)+sin(x)+∑sin(kx) from 4 to 2016
    Or [∑sin(kx) from 1 to N-3]=∑sin(kx) from 1 to 2016
    Now comparing upper limits of both sides we get N-3=2013
    so N=2019

  • JHawk24
    JHawk24 5 months ago +3

    It's 2019 because it's the new year and it is the only answer that I would expect. It is also in red above the question.

  • Hiren Bavaskar
    Hiren Bavaskar 5 months ago

    The answer is 2019 :)
    First things first, convert tan3x as sin3x/cos3x and hence multiply both sides by cos3x..On LHS,it turns out to be summation from i=2014 to N of sin(i-3)x...on RHS convert 2sin3xcos(ix) into [sin(i+3)x - sin(i-3)x ] + sin3x.. Now as u write the terms of the summation , the only things left are sin2011x + sin2012x+...+sin2016x. Compare the RHS by writing the terms of summation of LHS, so we compare the last term i.e sin(N-3)x = sin 2016x , therefore N-3=2016 i.e N=2019 is the answer and you are done !

    • Hiren Bavaskar
      Hiren Bavaskar 5 months ago

      Correction* ,the RHS was sin3x + summation from i=1 to 2013 of 2sin3xcos(ix) which gets converted to sin3x+[sin(i+3)x - sin(i-3)x]

  • Beshoy Nabil
    Beshoy Nabil 5 months ago +5

    Answer: 2019
    Multiplying both sides by cos(3x) then simplifying using the law of sin of sum of two angles, we get:
    sum(i=2014 to N) of sin(i-3)x = sin(3x) + sum(i=1 to 2013) of sin(i+3)x - sum(i=1 to 2013) of sin(i-3)x
    Rephrasing the index and using the telescoping series in the RHS, we get:
    sum(i=2011 to N-3) of sin(ix) = sin(3x) + sum(i=2011 to 2016) of sin(ix) - sum(i=-2 to 3) of sin(ix)
    Using the odd property of sine function, the last series vanishes with the sin(3x) term, so we get:
    sum(i=2011 to N-3) of sin(ix) = sum(i=2011 to 2016) of sin(ix)
    Since the identity is valid for all real x, we are obliged to have N-3=2016 so N=2019
    HINT: It would be a bit harder if not all real values of x but only for x=a/b *pi for certain conditions of a and b. It would have then another values for N.

    • Beshoy Nabil
      Beshoy Nabil 5 months ago

      That's a special case because x-x=0 for all x but in our case sin(2017x) + sin(2018x) + ... will not vanish except for certain values of x not all real possible variables of x as your series.

  • Reygan Dionisio
    Reygan Dionisio 5 months ago +2

    2019 is it

  • Lucio Antonio Rosi
    Lucio Antonio Rosi 5 months ago +3


  • Vampianist3
    Vampianist3 5 months ago +4

    Yeah...the answer is 2019
    Firstly, multiplying both sides by cos(3x) gets rid of tan(3x), using compound angle formula for LHS and product to sum formula for RHS and rearranging gives
    sum_1^N(sin(i-3)x)=sin(3x)+sum_1^2013(sin(i+3)x). (Man this is hard to type......)
    both sides are sines, LHS sums from sin(-2x) to sin((N-3)x) (which is essentially from 3 to N-3 because sine is odd) and RHS sums from sin(3x) to sin(2016x),so we have

    Really hard to type equations so I skipped some steps. Hopefully it’s OK. (Also I was about to use Euler’s identity for cos(ix) in the beginning lol)

  • Smokie Bear 🔴🔵
    Smokie Bear 🔴🔵 5 months ago +25

    The only answer is 2019 because the year is 2019. Easy peasy lemon squeezy