Everything Wrong With Mary Poppins In 15 Minutes Or Less

  • Published on Dec 13, 2018
  • With the new Mary Poppins sequel upon us, we decided to test our motto and go looking for sins in the original. And we found some. A bunch, actually.
    Next week: Something super and something seasonal.
    Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
    Patreon: www.patreon.com/CinemaSins
    Podcast: soundcloud.com/cinemasins
    TVSins: usclip.net/channel/UCe4bOvc1mYxFcQ5xPb9Zmow
    MusicVideoSins: usclip.net/channel/UCUBq8oBRVTsMpjWiHfjJpDw
    Jeremy: twitter.com/cinemasins
    Barrett: twitter.com/musicvideosins
    Aaron: twitter.com/aarondicer
    Jonathan: twitter.com/samloomis13

    Subreddit: reddit.com/r/cinemasins
    Website: cinemasins.com
    SinCast Facebook page: facebook.com/SinCastCinemaSins Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasins-store
  • Film & AnimationFilm & Animation

Comments • 6 297

  • Torpedo Marsh
    Torpedo Marsh 4 hours ago

    Jeremy, are you there? The Dumbo remake is coming out this March 29th. What’s it going to be? Everything Wrong With Dumbo (1941) or Operation: Dumbo Drop?

  • Jonathan Constant
    Jonathan Constant 15 hours ago

    FUCK I'm trying to watch this at work and can't keep my composure.

  • The Bling Games
    The Bling Games 2 days ago +1

    Funny thing i am watching the mary poppins anniversary addition and no I am not an adult I just like Mary Poppins and I'm a kid I don't care that saying your name is something to not do on USclip at first but I still do it anyway yeh age and I just gained 500 sins

  • Somnia Lillies
    Somnia Lillies 3 days ago

    12:11 I did
    I DID

  • Buffaloat
    Buffaloat 3 days ago

    3:20: I have never laughed harder

  • NoThanks :v
    NoThanks :v 3 days ago +1

    1:38 Yes...just yes. I live for that Hamilton reference.

  • Gregory Jewell
    Gregory Jewell 3 days ago

    I got a fever, and the only prescription is more supercalifragilisticexpialidociousness.

  • Mr Hadron
    Mr Hadron 4 days ago

    4:59 Mary Poppins is a timelord

  • Paul Cooke
    Paul Cooke 7 days ago

    4:40 I can't believe you didn't point out that Mary Poppins literally blew the competition away.

  • Paul Cooke
    Paul Cooke 7 days ago

    At 2:35 I'm surprised you didn't sin Mr. Banks for songsposition, then sin him again for merely expositioning in time with the music rather than actually singing.

  • Bartonovich52
    Bartonovich52 7 days ago

    It’s called an establishing shot.
    And before Star Wars... they had to put credits before the movie.

  • paul sullivan
    paul sullivan 8 days ago

    Cinema sin not mentioned: those are American Robins in London! (London would have had a different species, also called Robin...) (paging Batman!)

  • just a fan
    just a fan 8 days ago

    Before I forget, IN the book Mary tells the banks children that the chimeny sweeps are like gaurdian angels. SO thats why they can do that stuff (the heads in the chimmenys)

  • just a fan
    just a fan 8 days ago

    I am so happy I am not the ONLY one that thought about the Home owners thing even as a kid. LOL.
    I love love love this movie as a kid, I justed to know ‘Spoonful full of Sugar’ like the back of my hand as a kid, even the mirror part! Julie Andrews is QUEEN. You should watch the move ‘Saving Mr. Banks’ its about the making of this movie, its really really really good.

  • Rebecca Lowe
    Rebecca Lowe 8 days ago

    Nope. No sins here - she’s practically perfect in every way

  • Lou Carvalho
    Lou Carvalho 9 days ago

    It's a fabulous video as a whole, but even if it weren't, it would've been worth it for the "spoonful of BS" song at the end. :D

  • Pansy Flower
    Pansy Flower 10 days ago

    Something I always wondered was...…. Was Bert in Love with Mary Poppins?

  • Mellow Shallow
    Mellow Shallow 10 days ago

    I believe this gonna end around 100 sins
    Go in the ending
    I was right

  • Meghan Herrighty
    Meghan Herrighty 12 days ago

    Please do Saving Mr. Banks. I love that movie as well as this one

  • Jerry Genes
    Jerry Genes 12 days ago

    1:20 the nanny is Elsa Lanchester, The Bride of Frankenstein!

  • Kyooty Pie
    Kyooty Pie 12 days ago

    Jeez disrespect he’s coming for the best movies I like to see you try and make a movie 😒 I’ll wait😂😂

  • Connor Dolan
    Connor Dolan 13 days ago

    Damn Disney was dark

  • Bored Brains
    Bored Brains 14 days ago

    I love this film, I love it,Dick van dike, Julie Andrews, the fact it’s based in Britain, I love it. I love it. As a child I ran about singing chim chimney chim chimney chim chim cheeroo. I love it!

  • Lady Onikara
    Lady Onikara 14 days ago

    I don't think that lamp that was lit when she took it out of her bag even HAS a power cord. I don't think I saw one.

  • Jack lee
    Jack lee 14 days ago

    Really made me chuckle, even if I didn’t understand a lot of that American accent or the reasoning behind some of the “wrongs” it’s a bit of lighthearted fun just as the film was. Highlighting the difference between the UK and the US is fun even if it is a little cringeworthy sometimes but should still be celebrated and enjoyed with an unbiased view

  • Philip Martin
    Philip Martin 20 days ago

    Everything Wrong With Captain America (1979) please

  • The 90210 Officer
    The 90210 Officer 20 days ago

    6:42 Way to give Nintendo ideas for Super Mario 64 30 years prior.

  • pepe the memer
    pepe the memer 20 days ago

    It’s weird. My complex is named Cherry Tree Lane. >.>

  • TastesLikeSatire
    TastesLikeSatire 21 day ago

    Subtitles are based off the script and actors don't always follow the script exactly. Also don't "real talk" us when you just admitted it's magic!

  • Hollie Walker
    Hollie Walker 21 day ago

    I’m Mary poppins in my school play 😖🥰🌈

  • Tony Montana
    Tony Montana 22 days ago

    Messing with my childhood....


  • Super Red
    Super Red 22 days ago

    Odd bit of information
    Dick van dykes voice coach was Irish ,that is why his ascent is so bad ( he has claimed )
    The pearly kings and queens have declared a fates

  • Joseph Leanos
    Joseph Leanos 23 days ago

    In short, Mary Poppins is perfect in every single way, but her movie is not.

  • Mike Stanfill
    Mike Stanfill 23 days ago

    You had me at "Suck my balls!"

  • Zoe Wilson
    Zoe Wilson 25 days ago

    One of my fav films after suiduide squad , hunger games beauty and the beast the grinch ,
    🎥🎥🎥🎥🎥🎥 Harry Potter Patrick demon of flt street

  • Mattie guy
    Mattie guy 27 days ago

    When he started singing Hamilton I died looool

  • Idiøt
    Idiøt 28 days ago

    Apparently a spoon full of sins is 1.

  • tgguitarguy
    tgguitarguy 29 days ago +1

    3:10 "Nanny Mcphee took this list and did the exact opposite of everything they said to make their own character. That should probably be a sin for Nanny Mcphee, but I'm sinning this movie for inspiring that awful one" *Ding*

  • Denise Nova
    Denise Nova 29 days ago

    About taking drugs: The main song is „A spoon full of sugar makes the medicine go down“. Setting is in 1910. There are hallucinations. Does that all ring a bell? - Absinth.

  • Gybbson Lesly
    Gybbson Lesly Month ago

    7:12 those are tortoises. Sin on cinema sins and marry popins. Interesting fact some turtles evolved from tortises and vice versa. No one knows which came first. I believe turtles.
    What came first, chicken or egg. Egg as they were laid by animals way before chickens existed.

  • Caitria world Animations!

    *Hamilton reference*

  • Max Metodiev
    Max Metodiev Month ago +2

    Do the new one

  • Virginia Clark
    Virginia Clark Month ago

    I love Mary Poppins. ❤ Virginia

  • ToastyCartoon97 Plays

    U suck bitch

  • Drew Welker
    Drew Welker Month ago

    Yas Hamilton references! My wig is snatched

  • Marah Scribbles
    Marah Scribbles Month ago


  • Sailor Planetos
    Sailor Planetos Month ago

    Could you please make 'Everything Wrong with Mary Poppins Returns'...? Pretty, pretty please with a spoonful of sugar on top....?

  • Dogbite
    Dogbite Month ago

    08:48 You're right! It DOES sound like the end of "Uncle F*cker".

  • zomgl2pnoobffs
    zomgl2pnoobffs Month ago

    6:24 Those are gay robins -- they're both male. Progressive stuff.

  • Lacey Fisher
    Lacey Fisher Month ago

    I love this 😅

  • YeeSoest
    YeeSoest Month ago

    Man, that "little hellions" reference made my day

  • Zoey Bell
    Zoey Bell Month ago


  • tgguitarguy
    tgguitarguy Month ago +1

    10:17 Feed the Birds was Walt's Favorite Song that the Sherman brothers wrote for the movie. It's deep, meaningful, and fantastic, if it bores you, you are watching the wrong movie dude.

  • Athena Tait
    Athena Tait Month ago

    I really did never realize how big the chimney sweep mafia is...

  • MiniKittyGamer
    MiniKittyGamer Month ago +2

    14:46 I shouldn't be laughing but I am omg I'm a terrible human being XD

  • Lava Networks
    Lava Networks Month ago


    Suck my balls!

  • Kim Thuwis
    Kim Thuwis Month ago

    This was my favourite movie when I was a child

  • Andrea Lake
    Andrea Lake Month ago

    That sin for the chonk horse is probably one of my favorite sins youve ever sinned

  • Almandine Fox
    Almandine Fox Month ago

    American robins don’t live in London

  • Almandine Fox
    Almandine Fox Month ago +2

    that Hamilton reference really caught me off guard lmao

  • Wiggle Worm
    Wiggle Worm Month ago

    Yay my all time favorite Disney live action film finally got a sins/goofs video! Thanks CinemaSins! Can you make Everything Wrong with Mickey’s Once and Twice Upon A Christmas next?

  • Earl Chaney
    Earl Chaney Month ago

    Good luck finding a feminist that does not completely love this movie. Without listing names of course I dated 3 women who Loved Mary Poppins. They were all threatened by everything, and all married men that are complete pushovers, like the type of man who on their birthday get to pee standing up, but just once that day. I actually feel sorry for those guys now. #OnYourFirstDateAskIfSheLikesMaryPoppins #YesThisIsATrueStory oh PS one of the women after me hearing her name one time (which her name was a first and middle name together i.e. Mary Lee or Laura Sue) I only once accidentally called her by her first name only , , , , , (eArThQuAKE!), , , , She Lost Her Shit! Instantly red flags went up and confetti came down from heaven - You've just escaped a horrible life, run, your Free!

  • Simon
    Simon Month ago

    5:32 Mary pulls items out of her handbag the same way you pull Sins out of your arse.

  • Claire Combs
    Claire Combs Month ago

    This commentary is hilarious

  • Chamomile Tea
    Chamomile Tea Month ago

    The fact that a video talking about how Mary Poppins is bad is a sin.

  • Chamomile Tea
    Chamomile Tea Month ago +1


  • Tarantulas & Lhasa Apsos

    DVD’s cockney accent is sooooooo bad, it makes me cringe! Yet it’s a British institution to watch this film every Christmas, along with Charlie and the chocolate factory (Gene Wilder, obviously) not the Jonny Depp monstrosity, Oliver and The Dambusters!

  • a35362
    a35362 Month ago

    Jeremy is the son of a Scott.

  • Daeneira Boivin
    Daeneira Boivin Month ago

    yes, someone has swallowed a spoon full of sugar, because at that time. medicine tasted like SHIIIIIIIIIIT so kids has a spoon full of sugar to literally help the medicine go down. hope you enjoyed this little taste of history

  • Blood Oath
    Blood Oath Month ago +1

    So the magic bag makes sense, but a lit lamp doesn't. Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

    • MariaThePotterNut
      MariaThePotterNut 23 days ago

      +Blood Oath Magic flying nanny having a bag that's bigger on the inside, some sort of trick to hold objects bigger than it appears to be (potentially limitless, who knows), that can be plausible, as we have already seen that magic is a thing in this universe, and it is a tool that would makes sense and be helpful with what she chooses to do with her magic. Changing the functionality of an object, that's different. batteries as we know them didn't exist yet, so there is no way for it to be powered from an internal source. It is very clearly not plugged in to anything, so can't say there's an electrical source in the bag, and it is definitely electric not flame. A lamp is still a lamp, and should work the same way no matter how it is transported. Especially when you consider it is 1910 in the movie and the level of technology that existed, it doesn't make any sense.

    • Blood Oath
      Blood Oath 23 days ago

      +MariaThePotterNut how tho?

    • MariaThePotterNut
      MariaThePotterNut 23 days ago

      The bag makes sense in the context of her being a magic nanny, but the lamp being lit as if it was already connected to electricity does not.

  • Beautiful Love
    Beautiful Love Month ago


  • Rex Palastanga
    Rex Palastanga Month ago +1

    How could you

  • Olivia McDonagh
    Olivia McDonagh Month ago

    Knowing this is done in jest (who doesn't adore this film?) I found this review hilarious.

  • William Uchtman
    William Uchtman Month ago

    How could you miss:
    A brother and sister sharing the same room? Someone will someday entering therapy.
    A carpet bag that is infinitely larger inside? What's keeping the kids from climbing inside and exploring the interior?
    Could they have been trapped in the artwork if someone walked by and scuffed it with their foot?
    Whose Uncle Albert is he? Mary's or Bert's

  • Quentin Greweldinger

    This is fucking gorgeous now gat your sin trigger finger away from this masterpiece

  • tommy telgenhoff
    tommy telgenhoff Month ago

    don't you dare do one of these on Mary Poppins returns

  • David Ganem
    David Ganem Month ago

    I swear to god i thought that was a TFS Hellsing reference

  • G4mmaLotus
    G4mmaLotus Month ago

    Watched the movie, then this video. I made half the same comments you did, some almost word for word.

  • Thomas Saldana
    Thomas Saldana Month ago

    12:15 "I would like to make one thing quite clear; I never explain anything."
    She should've been sinned for explaining that she never explains.

  • Will Christenson
    Will Christenson Month ago

    How did the admiral calling the chimney sweeps hottentots which is a slang term for South Africans during the war not make it into this video?

  • SaraDerps
    SaraDerps Month ago +1

    This was one of my favorite movies as a kid but yeah
    This was a weird heccing movie 😅

  • isaac flores
    isaac flores Month ago

    Can you do bird box?

  • Ellie
    Ellie Month ago

    nope there's nothing wrong

  • Violet_Gacha 26
    Violet_Gacha 26 Month ago

    You guys need to do Mary Poppins Returns, I counted heaps of sins by myself

  • Blueberryymuffin
    Blueberryymuffin Month ago

    Chitty chitty bang bang next! It was my favourite childhood movie! Ruin my memories!

  • BurntFaceMan
    BurntFaceMan Month ago

    Are you seriously fat shaming a cartoon horse?? Harsh man.

  • ChronosZero86
    ChronosZero86 Month ago

    Is it just me or does the little girl look just like Karl Smallwood from Fact Fiend?

  • Abby Wolffe
    Abby Wolffe Month ago

    To be fair, I could listen to Julie Andrews sing about "tuppence a bag" for hours.

  • Bingo bongo
    Bingo bongo 2 months ago +1

  • hervainsoul
    hervainsoul 2 months ago +1

    did you just........

  • Cristian Guerrero
    Cristian Guerrero 2 months ago

    "buy me a beeerrr!!!! two bucks a glass...!!!!"

  • Isaac Wilhelm
    Isaac Wilhelm 2 months ago

    Gary IN shout out.

    And yes, Prestige is better.

  • Michel van der Linden
    Michel van der Linden 2 months ago

    15:01 has no business being this funny XD

  • James Hubacher
    James Hubacher 2 months ago

    I agree not much in this movie made sense. Pretty funny way to put everything.

  • Toto Thedi
    Toto Thedi 2 months ago

    Hey about upgrade, it has an intreguing plot, think about it!!!!

  • Evan clash of clans
    Evan clash of clans 2 months ago

    My high school did this play and in if we had people "fly" where the were hooked up to cables and pulled up into the air and during the roof top scene Bert would walk up a wall then on the the cealling and tap dance, and during one of our performances their were a couple of kids in the audience that were high and freaked out during that scene.

  • Mary Poppins
    Mary Poppins 2 months ago

    Roll supercalifragilisticexpialidocits XD I'm dying!

  • Mary Poppins
    Mary Poppins 2 months ago

    Nannicide XD

  • Mary Poppins
    Mary Poppins 2 months ago

    This is the only video of yours that I do not like, and that's only because I'm obsessed with Julian Andrews. Go on!

  • Sarah McCausland - Lorne Park SS (2252)